Classic Potato Salad

Potato salad in a serving bowl

Who made the Potato Salad? One thing is for sure & two things for certain, you will not find any raisins in the Potato Salad at our holiday table because my cousin Coco holds it down!

She is the type of cook that can taste a bite of something & accurately tell you every single ingredient in the recipe. It really is a gift. So when she tasted my Potato Salad & gave it her stamp of approval, I knew I had passed the vibe check.

The secret? Cooking the potatoes just right so they’re not too firm & not too mushy. Get into this winning recipe for FREE straight from my best selling eCookbook “And Just Like That… Soulful Holiday Recipes Made Easy!” #LetsVibe

Classic pototo salad in a serving bowl with fresh dill garnish

Ingredients

2.5 lbs Yukon Gold Potatoes, cubed

1 Tbsp Sea Salt

Wet Ingredients

1/2 cup Mayonnaise

4 oz Cream Cheese

1 Tbsp Dill Pickle Juice

1/4 cup Sweet Relish

2 Tbsp Diced Pimentos

2 Tbsp Yellow Mustard

1 Tbsp Dijon Mustard

Seasoning Blend

1/2 tsp Paprika

1/2 tsp Sea Salt

1/2 tsp Black Pepper

1 tsp Lawry’s Seasoned Salt

1 tsp Celery Salt

1 tsp Granulated Onion

1/2 tsp Granulated Garlic

2 Tbsp White Sugar

Mix-Ins

1 Tbsp Fresh Dill Leaves

2 Tbsp Diced Celery

2 Tbsp Diced Onion

2 Large Hard Boiled Eggs, Diced

Vegan Substitutes

mayonnaise —> vegan mayo

cream cheese —> vegan mayo or avocado

hard boiled eggs —> extra firm tofu

Classic potato salad in serving bowl with dill garnish and serving spoon on the side

Instructions

Wash, peel & cut potatoes in 3/4” cubes before adding to empty pot with sea salt then covering potatoes by 1/2” with cold water

Bring pot to a boil over medium heat & let cook for 8-10 minutes once boiling

After boiling 8-10 minutes drain cooked potatoes in a strainer but do not rinse cooked potatoes off

While potatoes are cooking combine all wet ingredients in a large mixing bowl & set aside

Combine all seasoning blend ingredients in a small dish & set aside

Add seasoning blend to mixing bowl with wet ingredients & fold in

Add mix-ins to mixing bowl with seasoned wet ingredients & fold in

Add cooked potatoes to mixing bowl with other ingredients & gently fold in until potatoes are well coated

Adjust seasoning to taste before allowing potato salad to chill a minimum 4 hours or overnight

Garnish chilled potato salad generously with paprika & enjoy!

@chefmikehard

Hi! I’m Mike. What’s the vibes?!
I’m a pro chef turned viral food content creator & recipe blogger. I’m from Chicago, IL with Southern roots & Caribbean heritage. I believe in the power of food & sharing #foodlove one bite at a time. Read More →

Previous
Previous

Creamy Coleslaw

Next
Next

Garlic Butter Steak Bites